I'm playing the fool in Twelfth Night and so have been pursuing the fool through books. I read A Social History of the Fool a few years ago now, but another look-in seemed appropriate.
It takes the notion of fools and fooling in a broader sense, including the use of fools in country traditions, in fairs, in Morris dancing and other areas. She also draws the evolution of the fool into the jester, then the jester into the professional comedian and the circus clown. A lot of the book deals with terminology and names - how a clown and fool are different, and how these are not quite the same as a Merry Andrew or a Jack Pudding. What Sandra Billington does not know about fools is not worth knowing but I have to say I was largely lost for much of the book.
Not anchoring the book in specific characters a lot of the time, I found it hard to keep up with what exactly was being said about what - it reminds me of the mind-fog I get every time I try to read actual literary criticism or philosophy. Also, there was far too much stuff in here about Morris dancing (except a lot of it wasn’t Morris dancing, according to the book but actually mumming, guizing, combat drama - and all other manner of things).
What I did take away from the book was that the notion of ‘fool’ is one that is constantly shifting with culture, either praised for guileless honesty or evil trickstering, taking country and city forms, borrowing from other cultures, changing positions and looks and jobs and being generally malleable to people’s needs and wishes.
I also learnt that the eighteenth-century chat about ‘pudding-eating’ means more than I realised. A pudding-eater, or a Jack Pudding is a brand of fool - and John Bull was originally formed in the image of this fool before becoming an honest-to-goodness representation of Britain. I don’t find this so strange as Britain often portrays itself as quite foolish.
The most interesting section was about mountebank salesman, their clowns and Merry Andrews. These are usually portrayed as swindling conmen who pretend to be doctors, use the clowns to get people’s attention and then proceed to flog useless or dangerous medicines. There’s a really good example of this in the old ‘Pete’s Dragon’ film. What the book argues, is that nobody was taken in by the claims for cures, that the mountebank principally gave news, satire and entertainment with the extravagant claims for the cures. Anyone that bought a vial would have done so to support the entertainment rather than hope for a cure. The arguments for this idea were presented very well, and I had all sorts of interesting book ideas pop into my head.
I can’t say I completely enjoyed this book. That is no fault for its focus, nor its academic style, it just wasn’t quite the book I was ready to read.
Not anchoring the book in specific characters a lot of the time, I found it hard to keep up with what exactly was being said about what - it reminds me of the mind-fog I get every time I try to read actual literary criticism or philosophy. Also, there was far too much stuff in here about Morris dancing (except a lot of it wasn’t Morris dancing, according to the book but actually mumming, guizing, combat drama - and all other manner of things).
What I did take away from the book was that the notion of ‘fool’ is one that is constantly shifting with culture, either praised for guileless honesty or evil trickstering, taking country and city forms, borrowing from other cultures, changing positions and looks and jobs and being generally malleable to people’s needs and wishes.
I also learnt that the eighteenth-century chat about ‘pudding-eating’ means more than I realised. A pudding-eater, or a Jack Pudding is a brand of fool - and John Bull was originally formed in the image of this fool before becoming an honest-to-goodness representation of Britain. I don’t find this so strange as Britain often portrays itself as quite foolish.
The most interesting section was about mountebank salesman, their clowns and Merry Andrews. These are usually portrayed as swindling conmen who pretend to be doctors, use the clowns to get people’s attention and then proceed to flog useless or dangerous medicines. There’s a really good example of this in the old ‘Pete’s Dragon’ film. What the book argues, is that nobody was taken in by the claims for cures, that the mountebank principally gave news, satire and entertainment with the extravagant claims for the cures. Anyone that bought a vial would have done so to support the entertainment rather than hope for a cure. The arguments for this idea were presented very well, and I had all sorts of interesting book ideas pop into my head.
I can’t say I completely enjoyed this book. That is no fault for its focus, nor its academic style, it just wasn’t quite the book I was ready to read.
No comments:
Post a Comment